I like the second deal and came up with this quick trick while playing around with the deal.

1. Have a card selected.
2. Control it to second from the top.
3. Turn over the top card and leave it face up on top of the deck while you ask "is this your card".
4. Double lift the face-up card with the face-down chosen card and use them to turn over the next card while you ask "is this your card".
5. Place the double card on top of the now face-up card and turn all three cards down.
6. Ask your spectator to hold out a hand palm up.
7. Second deal the chosen card onto the palm up hand.

The appearance of the face up card is quite startling.